Getting good at guitar and being creative--oil and water?!?
I can't even begin to count the number of times I have said to myself, \"Okay, today is the day I'm gonna sit down, and get serious about scales.\" Inevitably, I am pumpin' out my favorite tune within minutes.
I consider myself to be a pretty creative person, which is what attracts me to art and music. Unfortunately, it seems like it takes a completely different personality to get really good at guitar. Every lesson I've ever seen in a guitar magazine seems suitable for an accountant, not a musician!!
I'm certainly wrong, because there are a lot of exceptionally creative musicians who built their chops through rote repitition. I suppose their dedication level is through the roof, or I just suck.
This is where I need help: I can create wonderful riffs, good accompaniments, and rippin' solos in my head. My goal is to be able to translate them to the fretboard on the fly. Right now, I can do this to some extent, but I usually end up hitting a bad note, which causes my mental muzak to go flying out the door! Does anyone have any suggestions?!? And don't say practice scales!
I consider myself to be a pretty creative person, which is what attracts me to art and music. Unfortunately, it seems like it takes a completely different personality to get really good at guitar. Every lesson I've ever seen in a guitar magazine seems suitable for an accountant, not a musician!!
I'm certainly wrong, because there are a lot of exceptionally creative musicians who built their chops through rote repitition. I suppose their dedication level is through the roof, or I just suck.
This is where I need help: I can create wonderful riffs, good accompaniments, and rippin' solos in my head. My goal is to be able to translate them to the fretboard on the fly. Right now, I can do this to some extent, but I usually end up hitting a bad note, which causes my mental muzak to go flying out the door! Does anyone have any suggestions?!? And don't say practice scales!

Comments
Classical pieces are good for for scale passages and arpeggios, if arranged. I like taking Well-Tempered Clavier pieces and arranging top and bottom voice for bass and guitar, respectively.
http://www.44lbs.net/ilia/dmin_tab_page1.tiff
http://www.44lbs.net/ilia/dmin_tab_page2.tiff
http://www.44lbs.net/ilia/dmin_tab_page3.tiff
http://www.44lbs.net/ilia/dmin_tab_page4.tiff
http://www.44lbs.net/ilia/dmin_tab_page5.tiff
I'd say patience & time. No substitute for putting time in the Wood Shedd. I don't know how long you been playing?? But I can only speak for myself. It seems the more things I have in the toolbox the more my freedom, expression and phrasing seem to get better & just fit better with who I play with. So yes I would say knowing Scales,Chords, Apergios, Lead Patterns in CAGED Sequence up down the neck is crucial to being able to play with anyone or anything, and make few mistakes because you know soooooooooo much that fits and can be played over & with the Music. Hey I have along time to go myself!!! But as I get smother at these things It just gets better & better!!! Well worth the time at the Wood Shedd!!!!
God Bless Jagesso!!!
Partch
P.S.
Maybee try Fretboard Logic By Bill Edwards. Realy good stuff!! Not hard to follow with very little Music guitar theory. Cheap & can work thru it at own pace I've not even got thru SE book yet in about a year. But I continue to improve!! I'm deffinetly much better for studying and trying to master the material!! Even if it is at a slow pace!!! Just my 2 cents
the best improve guitarist are able to hear whats going on in the song their playing-hear what they want to do (ine their head ) and play it . That takes work and I'm not there but I want to be ...maybe some day.
I suppose for some who are gifted(not me)it's not very hard but for the rest of us it takes alot of work and plenty of experience improving over different kinds of music. Sometimes I like to turn on the radio and jam to different stations(especially jazz). I'd like to think it helps me in this area of timing and placement of notes.
Iliace, I don't see anything when I click on those links. I tried both IE and Firefox. I am interested in seeing them.
Philflood, I've also heard that singing every note you play (or your solfeggio approach) is a very effective way to achieve my goal. Maybe that's the step I'm missing--I need to go from my mind to my mouth, then to the fretboard. Time to triple up on sound-proofing materials and Coors.
Are just tools to have in your tool box...
Tedious and boring at times, but necesarry to have the proper tools.
Think about framing a house with only a tack hammer...
Would be pretty hard..
Same way with the guitar..
Hard to build a solid solo without the proper tools to build with.
The artistic part is how the carpenter uses his tools to put the house together..
See Ya,
Tal.. 8)
And ditto on what Philflood & Grathan said